If you were hoping last week would settle the question of where mortgage rates go next, it did the opposite. Freddie Mac's weekly survey showed the average thirty-year rate falling for a fourth straight week, to its lowest level in seven weeks. Then a hotter than expected inflation report landed, and by Friday the daily rate trackers had given back most of that improvement.
So here is my short answer for Michigan buyers and sellers: the rate dip I wrote about in last Monday's update has been tested, and for now it has mostly lost. The Federal Reserve meets again in early December and markets widely expect a rate hike. That makes this a week to get your paperwork and your plan in order, not a week to wait and see.
What happened last week
Three reports did most of the work.
- Inflation came in hot. On Tuesday the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that consumer prices rose more in October than economists had forecast. Core prices, which leave out food and energy, rose at the same pace for the third month in a row. According to HousingWire's coverage, shelter costs were still one of the larger pieces of the monthly increase.
- Freddie Mac's weekly average fell again. Thursday's survey showed a fourth straight weekly decline. That survey collects applications over several days, so most of what it measured came before the bond market finished reacting to the inflation numbers.
- Home sales hit a sixteen-year low. The National Association of Realtors reported that existing-home sales in October fell to their slowest pace since 2010. The number of homes for sale was higher than a year ago, homes took a little longer to sell, and the national median price was only slightly above last year's.
A producer price report on Friday came in a touch softer than expected, but it was not enough to calm the bond market. Mortgage News Daily, which tracks lender rate sheets every day, reported that average rates climbed over three days and erased most of the improvement of the previous five weeks.
Why a weekly average and a daily quote can disagree
This confuses a lot of people, so let me explain it the way I would at the kitchen table. The Freddie Mac number in the headlines is an average of the past week. The quote you get from a lender is priced off the bond market that morning. When the market turns quickly, the headline can say rates fell while the quotes people actually receive are moving up.
Neither number is wrong. They measure different things. If you are shopping for a home right now, the headline tells you the trend over the last month, and a current quote for your own situation tells you what you can do today. Your own quote also depends on your credit, your down payment, the loan program and the property, which no national average can capture.
What the Fed's December meeting means for you
The Fed held its benchmark rate steady in October. Its next decision comes on December 9. After last week's inflation report, news coverage of the futures market showed traders treating a December increase as likely, and one Fed governor said publicly that a larger than usual move should be on the table.
Here is the part many buyers miss. The Fed does not set mortgage rates. Mortgage rates follow the bond market, and the bond market moves on what investors expect the Fed to do, usually well before the meeting. A good share of an expected hike is typically reflected in mortgage pricing by the time it is announced. That is why rates moved last week, a month ahead of the decision.
I will not predict where rates are headed, and I would be careful with anyone who does. What I can tell you is that there are a few more reports between now and that meeting, and each one can move pricing on the day it comes out. If you are under contract or close to it, talk with your lender about when a rate lock makes sense for your closing date instead of trying to time the news.
What the sales numbers mean in West Michigan
The national slowdown is showing up close to home, with a twist that helps buyers. According to the West Michigan Lakeshore Association of Realtors, which covers Allegan, Muskegon and Ottawa counties, closed sales in October were well below October of last year while the number of active listings was higher. The association also reported that results varied by county: the median sale price was up from a year ago in Ottawa and Muskegon counties and down in Allegan County.
The Realtors' national report showed the same pattern for the Midwest as a whole, with sales slipping and prices still modestly above last year's.
Put plainly, that is fewer buyers competing and more homes to choose from, without the broad price drops some people keep waiting for.
If you are buying
Higher rates are a real hurdle and I will not pretend otherwise. But more listings and slower sales usually mean more room to do the things buyers had to skip in the frenzy years: a proper inspection, time to think overnight, and a conversation about the seller helping with some of your costs. Whether a seller agrees depends on the house and the offer, and how much help a loan program allows depends on the program.
The buyers who can use that room are the ones who are already approved. If you have not started, my guide on how to get pre-approved for a mortgage in Michigan walks through the documents and the timeline. Approval always depends on your full application.
If you are selling
Your home is competing with more listings than it would have a year ago, and winter is coming. Pricing to the current market matters more than it did, and so does being ready for an inspection request. I covered the seasonal side in when to sell your house in Michigan.
If you are selling one home to buy the next, the order you do things in matters even more in a slower market. My post on buying and selling at the same time lays out the options.
What to do this week
- Get a current quote for your own situation. Headlines are averages. Ask for numbers based on your credit, your down payment and the kind of home you want, and ask to see more than one loan program side by side.
- Refresh an older pre-approval. If yours was written a month or more ago, the budget behind it was built on different rates. Have it updated before you write an offer so there are no surprises.
- Ask how rate locks work. Find out how long a lock lasts, what happens if your closing is delayed, and what your options are if rates improve after you lock. Policies differ by lender and program.
- Gather your documents now. Recent pay stubs, the last two years of tax forms and current bank statements. Having them ready means you can move quickly when the right house shows up.
- Sellers, look at your competition. Ask your agent what has come on the market near you in the past month and how long those homes have been sitting.
- Do not rearrange your life around one Fed meeting. Buy or sell when the house, the budget and your plans line up. If they do, call or text me and I will walk through the options with you.